is disney cruise line concierge worth it? An honest answer after 8 cruises
- 3 days ago
- 10 min read
One of the questions I’m asked at least once a day is “Is concierge on Disney Cruise Line really worth it?” And I get it. This is not a $30/night view upgrade. The prices are often double or 2.5x a cabin of the same size, just without the concierge status.
I’ve wavered on this myself, as I’ve cruised Disney 8x since mid-2022 in cabins from the smallest to the second largest. Would’ve been more but I threw in Explora (review here) and NCL’s Pride of America (don’t ask) as well (not to mention the Star Suite on Royal next week…). I’ve done the 3-night Bahamas to the 9-night Greek Isles, the Halloween on the High Seas, the Very Merrytime, the buffet at 7am before a big port day, and the breakfast delivered to a suite while my husband slept until nine. So while I know plenty of nerds who’ve cruised Disney 2 and 3 and 4x as much as I have, I do know what I’m talking about.
My first concierge experience was a one-bedroom suite on the Fantasy for a Very Merrytime cruise in December 2022. We barely made that sailing because my daughter broke her arm in Magic Kingdom the night before (now THAT'S a story) and when we got to the port there was a small sign that said, "upgrades available." It cost as much to upgrade to the suite as our original cabin had cost. I was in full YOLO mode by that point, so we did it. That suite was the highlight of the cruise and completely ruined me. Couldn't get my kids out of the bathtub with the mirror TV. Couldn’t make my husband eat in the dining room.
So, my infuriating short answer: it depends. (Better than YES, ALWAYS?). Long answer below.
Surely, I don’t have to do this…
No, you don’t have to take your kids on a Disney cruise. But if you have the means, and your kids are between the ages of 3 and 10, you should. Really.
The thing that gets me every time is how much the whole family ends up doing together. The shows are genuinely Broadway-caliber, an hour long (yes, even your 4yo can handle it), and the whole family goes. Trivia, game shows, crafting sessions, themed deck parties -- these are things where you look around and realize you're all actually having fun at the same time, not just in the same vicinity. Your kids are so delighted you can't help but smile.
And then when you've had enough togetherness? They disappear into the kids' club, which is so good that you don't feel guilty about it. Disney has a lock on the kids' club game by a long shot. It's immersive, secure, and staffed by people who clearly enjoy working there. You nap on the adults-only deck with zero guilt because you know they're having the time of their lives. And if you’re a Star Wars nerd, you go in there with them during the open house hours and wish they’d had cool stuff like this when you were a kid.
There's also no drink package, which sounds like a downside until you realize it means significantly fewer people who are, let's say, enthusiastically overserved. The vibe is noticeably different from other large ships for exactly this reason (unlike the only ship that leaves from my town’s port, which smells like a music festival). No judgment, y’all have fun, but less to explain to the kids for me.
Standard vs. concierge rooms
The entry-level concierge rooms are the exact same square footage as the category right below them, the “deluxe family oceanview with verandah.” With entry-level concierge, you're not paying for space. You're paying for access and service.
The exception is what I call the "secret suites." There are a couple on each Wish-class ship (Wish, Treasure, Destiny), no verandah (not a dealbreaker for us), around 530 square feet, with a king bedroom that closes off completely. They're priced close to the standard concierge ocean view verandah and they book extremely fast because they're an absurd value.
The true one-bedroom suites have two bathrooms, a soaking tub that would fit at least one of the inside cabins I had in my 20s on a Princess Alaska sailing, sleeping for five, and full in-suite dining. Suite guests also get noticeably more attentive host service… nothing I can point to officially, but after booking hundreds of Disney cruises I'm very confident suite guests are more likely to have their concierge requests fulfilled, especially on larger ships.
A quick note if size is all that matters, and lines and crowds don’t up your BP: if small cabin sizes worry you, Disney has the largest cabins of any mass market line. And if you need separate sleeping areas, a suite isn't your only option. DCL ships were built for families and have far more connecting cabins than lines like Princess or Holland America. I always price-check connecting cabins against suites for clients motivated primarily by space. Sometimes the gap is small enough that the suite makes obvious sense, and sometimes connecting cabins are enough.
This is what the category directly below concierge looks like; we had a connecting room with friends.
So if most of the rooms are the same, why pay double?
For the same reason you pay to skip the lines at a Disney park. The ride itself doesn’t change; that’s the same whether you wait 5m or 5 hours. But how much you enjoy it surely does. Here are the big pain points concierge solves, IMO:
1. getting on and off the ship
To me, this is the starkest contrast between standard and concierge, especially with my two most recent sailings.
Without concierge, you do online check-in at midnight on your assigned day, uploading passport photos, selfies, signing waivers. Because of the waivers, I can't do this for you (my lawyer won't let me). Miss that window on a busy sailing and you may end up with a late boarding time. On a three-night cruise (2 full days plus however long you’re on the boat embarkation day), that's a meal and two to five hours at the pool you paid for and never got. And if it’s your first cruise, you’re doing check-in on the last possible day. Everything Disney does is by seniority, and concierge gets you status equivalent to 50+ cruises.
On our Destiny Easter sailing, I had a decent port arrival time with Gold status, but we took Disney's shuttle from the Hilton Fort Lauderdale Marina (Disney offers shuttles from 3 not great hotels; skip them and stay at the FS, if you book with a preferred partner they include your cruise transfer). Two hours from joining the bus queue to stepping on the ship. By the time we cleared security they were calling Group 10. My boarding group advantage was completely irrelevant. (This is port-specific, it's not as bad in Port Canaveral.)
On the Treasure in concierge, I filled out check-in whenever I remembered. Boarding Group 1 is automatic. We arrived by private car, porters took our bags, walked through an empty concierge lane, got our sticker, and waited in a private lounge. The lounge is fine, Disney could do a LOT better here honestly, but the moment the ship cleared port authority the concierge host walked us on. They host a private lunch in the nicest dining room for concierge guests, and all the concierge hosts will come by and get to know you, but honestly? Skip this and enjoy a very empty boat while you can!
Getting off the ship is just as big a deal. Standard disembarkation: luggage out by 10pm the night before, host knocks at 7:30am, wait for your character group to be called, join a line that snakes around the ship for 15-45 minutes. With concierge, you chat with the host about luggage the night before, the next am the host walks you down a staff elevator past the entire line to a dedicated agent. Done.
2. how you experience the crowds
Disney ships hold between 2500-4000 passengers. Concierge doesn't make that number smaller, but it changes how much of it you have to navigate.
Breakfast at the buffet is… my husband’s personal hell, apparently. On a calm sea day the buffet is fine, much better than other mass market lines. On a port-intensive itinerary where everyone is rushing off the ship at once, it becomes a scene. The newer ships' non-self-serve model is more hygienic but slows things down considerably. The coffee is bad, the good coffee line is long, and finding a table is a project.
The concierge lounge? Rotating hot menu every morning with five or six options plus continental buffet, an espresso machine you just use. The suite option is a full hot breakfast delivered to your in-room dining table, whatever you want. If it's in budget, this is the way to go. Your kid gets Mickey churro waffles in their PJs, you get to dry your hair.
The concierge lounge also has open bar hours, drinks and snacks all day, and roving hosts who solve problems without a 45-minute guest services wait. The concierge sun deck has a private pool and/or hot tub, upgraded loungers, a bar, far fewer people and is where my husband spent most of his downtime on the Treasure. It completely replaced the $400 spa rainforest room pass my husband bought on previous non-concierge sailings.
3. your experience of the shows and dining
The shows are Broadway quality with actual Broadway performers… puppets, visual effects, smoke-filled bubbles and confetti falling from the ceiling for the tots, just good stuff. They're an hour long, the whole family goes, and if you don't see them you're missing the entire point of the cruise, really.
Without concierge, prime seats require lining up 30-45 minutes early while someone else from your party lines up for popcorn and drinks. With concierge, you meet in the lounge, get walked down a staff elevator to a separate entrance that feeds into the orchestra section, and choose your seat before anyone else is in the building. You're not saving time, but you’re saving a lot of hassle by only competing for the best seats with a handful of concierge guests instead of half a 4,000-person ship.
Dinner seating placement matters more than most people expect. On the Treasure in concierge we were right next to the Coco stage, with performers coming past our table, completely immersive and awesome memories. On the Destiny without concierge for Lion King, I could hear the music and see the lighting but only marginally see the performance. I suspect how much I enjoyed the dinner shows had more to do with my seat than with the quality of the performers or the show itself.
Concierge also gets first access to book the adults-only dining experiences. This matters specifically for the Enchanté dessert and Palo/Remy brunch, both of which do sell out.
4. the smaller stuff that adds up
First access to cabanas at Castaway Cay and Lookout Cay: hit or miss for regular concierge rooms on larger ships. I requested one on the Treasure right at the 130-day mark and didn't get it. I’ve never (knock on wood) had a suite guest not get their requested cabana(s). If you’re not concierge and don’t have time to sit on the app refreshing constantly for 120 days before your cruise, there’s zero chance you’ll get a cabana, at all.
First access to high-demand experiences like Olaf's Royal Picnic and Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique as well as popular excursions. One special character meet exclusive to concierge is a nice touch, not a game-changer. Character lines are their own whole situation that concierge doesn't really solve.
the real numbers
Original Treasure booking (7-night Eastern Caribbean first week of March, standard veranda for 4, booked as soon as itineraries dropped): $8,500. Price after upgrading to secret suite: $19,500.
Destiny sailing (4-night Bahamian, Easter, 3 guests, booked 6 months out, category just under concierge): ~$7,000.
The Fantasy suite would have been $36,000 at full Christmas pricing. We paid about half because of a COVID cancellation and a port upgrade sign. On my last 5 sailings, port upgrades were offered on exactly 1, and no suites were available. Don't book coach expecting to lie flat.
so is it worth it?
After the Fantasy suite, we were ruined. But we also like to travel often, and I can’t do 7 or 8 trips a year if I’m paying suite prices on DCL. So we went back to a regular room for our next cruise. We did not die!
But the husband insisted that we upgrade for the Treasure after I showed him the room. Given the 100%+ mark up, I still wasn’t sure. As a child of the Disney Renaissance, if I can hear Robin Williams sing “Friend Like Me” while I’m walking down the hallway, I don’t care that it’s to get in a line.
Then I did the Destiny Easter sailing without concierge and felt like I spent half my vacation in those dang lines. Boarding, breakfast, dinner seating, pool chairs… all of it required more effort than it should have. It wasn't a bad trip. It just wasn't as good as it could have been.
So now, yes. Absolutely worth it. Not because any single perk is transformative, but because the accumulation of them changes the feeling of the whole trip. It's the difference between a vacation that's fun for the kids but exhausting for you and one that actually feels a bit luxurious and restorative despite being very much a ship full of children.
In short: if you're used to luxury travel, don't sail in a standard room with expectations of frictionless adventure. Think of it like this -- either way, you're staying in a Mouse-themed Hyatt Regency (and I book and have stayed in my fair share of great HRs). But in one version you're on group bus tours, eating with 2,000 other people every meal, and sharing a pool with all of them. In the other, you have private tours for everything, a concierge who's genuinely helpful, skip-the-line access for shows, and much calmer meals and pool time.
one more thing
There's a lot to know before you book: which ships match your family, which itineraries work for first-timers, which cabin locations to request and which to avoid, and how to actually use everything the ship offers, from Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique to the Star Wars bar to which shore excursions are worth it.
If you have the time and inclination to figure all of that out yourself, go for it. Most people I know don't, and don't want to. That's pretty much what I'm here for. Disney cruising is about 20% of my business, and I think a well-timed and planned concierge-level cruise is a great addition to any family's vacation lineup. Feel free to reach out for help with your next cruise!
Comments